One Star Short of Murder: A Spilled Beans Mystery – Book Review
One Star Short of Murder is a witty, truly cozy mystery that puts a decidedly modern spin on the typical small-town whodunit. The premise is intriguing right away: a barista dies in what authorities are calling an accident, then her account leaves a terrible one-star review of the coffee shop two hours later. From there, Maggie Parberger spins a story involving manipulated online reviews, local gossip and people who know a lot more than they let on.
Maya Novak is one hell of an amateur sleuth. She’s a computer engineering graduate with a spreadsheet for everything and a tendency of grading gossip by how many people it’s passed through. That blend of analytical thought, keen observation, and social awkwardness makes her a refreshing lead character.
Maya’s instincts are far from faultless, but her curiosity and increasing willingness to trust people give the mystery its heart, as well as its puzzle-solving.
Spilled Beans itself is one of the book’s finest ingredients. The regulars at the coffee shop feel like a real community, not the usual stock of odd characters, each playing a specific part in the plot. The retired crossword-solving teacher, the sudoku queen, the EMT-in-training and gruff owner Walt provide humor, warmth and just enough suspicion to make the investigation interesting. The setting makes Haverlock sound like a place that readers will want to return to again and again for fresh mysteries.
Parberger also plays well with the fundamental theme of review manipulation. The book looks at the impact of online reviews on small businesses and the speed at which rumors may spread when people assume they know the full story. It gives the mystery contemporary stakes, but yet delivers the comfort readers anticipate from the genre: coffee, baked goods, a close-knit group of regulars, and a Great Dane with a weakness for pie.
The plot proceeds at a satisfying clip, balancing clues, character moments, and humorous observations without getting too gloomy. It’s a clean mystery, with no graphic violence or explicit scenes, but it never seems lightweight.
One Star Short of Murder is a strong start to a series for fans of coffee-shop cozies, amateur sleuths, found family, and a mystery with a smart, digital-age hook. It was the perfect little cozy mystery to start off the fall season and I can’t wait to read more in this series.
One Star Short of Murder: A Spilled Beans Mystery by Maggie Parberger
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
One Star Short of Murder is a witty, truly cozy mystery that puts a decidedly modern spin on the typical small-town whodunit. The premise is intriguing right away: a barista dies in what authorities are calling an accident, then her account leaves a terrible one-star review of the coffee shop two hours later. From there, Maggie Parberger spins a story involving manipulated online reviews, local gossip and people who know a lot more than they let on.
Maya Novak is one hell of an amateur sleuth. She’s a computer engineering graduate with a spreadsheet for everything and a tendency of grading gossip by how many people it’s passed through. That blend of analytical thought, keen observation, and social awkwardness makes her a refreshing lead character.
The plot proceeds at a satisfying clip, balancing clues, character moments, and humorous observations without getting too gloomy. It’s a clean mystery, with no graphic violence or explicit scenes, but it never seems lightweight.
It’s a strong start to a series for fans of coffee-shop cozies, amateur sleuths, found family, and a mystery with a smart, digital-age hook. It was the perfect little cozy mystery to start off the fall season and I can’t wait to read more in this series.
View all my reviews on Goodreads